Harvey reaches $60,000 settlement in wrongful police detention lawsuit
Austin Whirl claimed he was wrongfully prosecuted by detectives Richard De Leon and Arthur Muhammad for a shooting that occurred in 2022. Whirl was in jail for two years before all charges were dropped due to insufficient evidence.

The Harvey City Council approved a $60,000 settlement agreement in the Whirl v. City of Harvey court case at the Nov. 9 meeting.
In January 2025, Austin Whirl filed a lawsuit against the city and detectives Richard De Leon and Arthur Muhammad claiming he was wrongfully arrested and indicted for attempted first-degree murder in a shooting involving a resident, a crime he asserts he did not commit. De Leon and Muhammad failed to provide sufficient evidence and reliable witness testimony that identified Whirl as the shooter. Despite this, Whirl spent over two years in jail and on house arrest until all charges were dropped in 2024 due to the lack of evidence.
According to the settlement agreement, the city will complete the payout in two installments: one payment of $30,000 issued by Dec. 31, and the remaining half issued by March 31, 2027. The council discussed the settlement in an executive session during a special meeting in early October.
During public comment, resident Ryan Sinwelski, who is currently running for 2nd Ward, raised questions about the settlement. He asked council members if De Leon and Muhammad faced any repercussions for the faulty charges and where the $60,000 payout would be coming from.
“I think you can legally address some of those things,” Sinwelski said. “I understand you can’t always discuss these settlements or lawsuits publicly, but I think we deserve to know that as Harvey residents.”
According to state records, DeLeon is no longer an active police officer in Harvey, as of January. Muhammad is no longer active in Harvey, as of June; he now works as an officer in Hickory Hills. It’s immediately unclear whether those separations were voluntary or Harvey fired them.
Lawsuit settlements are often passed on to residents in the form of property tax increases and show up as a payment on a bills list. As an alderman during the Kellogg administration, now acting mayor Shirley Drewenski supported efforts to bring in the Cook County Sheriff’s Office to act as Harvey’s inspector general.
During the Clark administration, she got quiet on the matter. Anthony Reese serves as Harvey’s inspector general but does not make findings public; it’s unclear how many investigations she has conducted and their results.
‘A sad week for Harvey’
The meeting began with a moment of silence for two former city employees who passed away earlier this month.
Dreina Lewis, former city chief administrator and older sister of former mayor Eric Kellogg, died on Nov. 2 at age 82. Lewis served as the city’s chief administrator for 16 years. Interim mayor Shirley Drewenski said Lewis knew everything about the city and that, “you cannot deny her passion.”
Just days later, Donald Nesbit, former 5th Ward alderman, died on Nov. 7. Nesbit served from 2003 to 2019. Beyond aldermanic duties, Nesbit was also a longtime educator and coach who served on the Harvey School District 152 board where his daughter, Casey Nesbit, is currently a board member. In an announcement, HSD 152 credited Nesbit for spearheading the district’s annual back-to-school parade and fair and for founding the famed Harvey Blue Angels dance and majorette team.
“Donald Nesbit has been an icon in Harvey,” Drewenski said. “Many of us knew him from the Blue Angels, and his many years of dedication not only to the school district, but to the city of Harvey as a whole.”
Residents discuss municipal election
During public comment, some residents shared their input on the upcoming municipal election. Chapelle Hooks, former Harvey Public Library trustee, voiced concerns over fairness in the electoral objection hearings, which kicked off the next day, and suggested the county should oversee them to ensure independence from political bias.
“We all know who sticks together,” Hooks said. “In order for everybody to be done fairly, I think the county should be doing these objections.” Hooks warned residents, “Everything’s gonna be the same ‘cause y’all voting in the same people that’s doing the same thing […] Everybody’s talking about the blue wave and all that. Ain’t nothing ever changed.”
Resident Glynis James-Watson, who is currently running for city treasurer, encouraged residents to conduct their own research ahead of the election. “Harvey isn’t blue, isn’t red […] It’s community.”
Aldermanic comment
Ald. Rosa Arambula (1st) said she has fielded concerns about Immigration and Customs Enforcement presence in Harvey and addressed a rumor that police allowed ICE agents to tail them while they followed a resident, who was allegedly then detained by ICE.
Arambula did not confirm whether the story was true. However, she said interim police chief Dale Mitchell told her they cannot legally assist ICE agents and proceeded to repeat the message in Spanish. Illinois’ TRUST Act prohibits local law enforcement from working with federal immigration enforcement.
Ald. Dominique Randle-El (5th) addressed residents who complained the city has not changed for the better. He claimed that the city has gained more opportunities since the Clark administration entered office because, “we presented a government that could be trusted, not one that had been raided by the FBI, not one that was sitting up under a microscope.”
Under this council class and the Clark administration, problems persist: state-mandated audits are delinquent, bills lists are not itemized and do not include critical payroll figures, costly lawsuits continue, and multiple mayoral staff members have been fired due to alleged insubordination. But that didn’t stop Randle-El from effectively kicking the can on residents’ complaints.
“We had changed the opinion of those on the state and federal and county level to the point that they were willing to assist,” Randle-El said. “We did have county trucks out here. We did have the sheriff out here. You’ve never seen that before because they wouldn’t come.”
Ald. Telanee Smith (3rd) complained that residents’ express discontent with leadership and suggested public comment be restricted to what is on the agenda.
We’re filling the void after the collapse of local newspapers decades ago. But we can’t do it without reader support.
Help us continue to publish stories like these
